The March 2026 Italian decision is important because it concerns more than individual fake reviews. It asks whether ratings, verification labels, invitation tools and paid services are explained well enough for consumers to understand what a score represents. The decision is being appealed.
On 23 March 2026, Italy's competition authority announced a €4 million fine against Trustpilot Group companies for what it described as an unfair commercial practice.
The ruling deserves careful attention—and careful wording. It is a regulatory decision, not proof that every Trustpilot review is false, and Trustpilot has announced that it will appeal.
What the Regulator Found
According to the Italian Competition Authority's English-language announcement, its investigation found that Trustpilot had not carried out adequate checks to ensure the authenticity of reviews published on the platform, including in cases where reviews were labelled verified.
The authority also said review-collection services allowed businesses to select consumers who received invitations, with implications for how representative the resulting ratings were.
Finally, it found that consumers did not receive sufficiently accessible information about how the platform worked, businesses' use of paid services and other matters relevant to interpreting ratings.
The authority described aspects of the interface as dark-pattern techniques and concluded that the combined conduct was misleading under the Italian Consumer Code.
What Trustpilot Says
Trustpilot has rejected the finding and announced that it will appeal.
Trustpilot's published position is that its rules prohibit review gating and incentives, that TrustScores are calculated automatically, and that paid plans do not allow employees or customers to manually alter scores.
Because an appeal is planned, reporting should present both the regulator's findings and Trustpilot's challenge rather than treating the dispute as finally settled.
Why “Verified” Matters
Consumers naturally give extra weight to a verified label. The case highlights why platforms should define that label precisely.
Did the platform verify a purchase, an invitation email, an identity, or simply that the review travelled through a particular collection route? Those are different levels of evidence.
A clear label should tell shoppers what has been confirmed and what has not.
Invitation Tools and Representativeness
A review can be genuine while the overall score remains unrepresentative. If invitations reach only a selected part of the customer base, every invited reviewer could be real and the sample could still be skewed.
That is why neutral invitation policies matter. Platforms should examine not only whether individual reviews are authentic, but also whether their collection tools enable businesses to filter which customer experiences become visible.
Rated Stores
Build a reputation customers actually trust.
Collect, verify and showcase genuine reviews — start free, no card required.
Get Started Free →Paid Services Need Visible Boundaries
Trustpilot operates a freemium model and sells subscriptions to businesses listed on its platform. That is not inherently improper.
It does mean consumers need clear answers about what payment changes. Analytics, widgets and automation can reasonably be paid features. Moderation outcomes and scoring should remain insulated from commercial relationships—and the separation should be understandable from outside the company.
What Businesses Should Do
Businesses using any review platform should:
- Invite customers through a neutral, representative process.
- Never reward a particular rating or hide incentives.
- Check what a verification label actually promises.
- Avoid displaying selected testimonials as though they represent the full profile.
- Keep a published review and moderation policy.
- Review platform guidance as well as local consumer law.
What Shoppers Should Do
Treat aggregate scores as summaries, not guarantees. Read the underlying distribution and recent reviews, check how feedback was collected and compare important decisions with other sources.
The ruling is a reason to ask better questions, not a reason to assume every contributor is dishonest.
Final Thoughts
The Italian case puts authenticity, representativeness and commercial transparency into the same conversation. That is valuable for the entire review industry.
Whatever happens on appeal, review platforms should be able to show—not merely assert—that their labels mean what shoppers think they mean and that paying businesses cannot shape the truth.
Explore more:
Keep reading

Why Are Fake Trustpilot Reviews Still for Sale?
Trustpilot removes millions of fake reviews and has sued review sellers. So why can businesses still find people promising reviews for sale?
Read article →
Review Gating Explained: Why Businesses Should Avoid It
Learn what review gating looks like, why it creates a misleading rating, and how to collect feedback fairly instead.
Read article →
Should I Buy Trustpilot Reviews? The Legal and Commercial Risks
Buying Trustpilot reviews can trigger legal, platform and reputational consequences. Here is what businesses should do instead.
Read article →